As such, it certainly makes sense to put links on file sharing systems to take them to sites where they can purchase the digital version if microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free really want to. This was a way to convert people into paying for the files. Why would Amazon want to block that? Filed Under: digital goodsfile sharingsales Companies: amazoncoda. Sad days, sad days indeed. And…how exactly are these people engaging in copyright infringement via Amazon, hmm?

In fact, they are contributing to a drop in copyright infringement, if anything, since they are offering legitimate content as an alternative to users whom might otherwise have pursued it from Coda.

Their actions make no sense—it reminds me of Egypt killing a bunch of pigs, ostensibly due to swine flu though it is not transmitted via pork. How is offering an option to turn infringers into buyers contributory infringement? Uh, but again, you have it backwards. This is not about supporting infringing. Pray tell, how are newspapers supporting a source that is fundementally microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free their business?

But it does make it less likely that people will become legal buyers. Get a proposition on the state ballot.

Amazon pays affiliates when clicked links turn into purchases, which create profits for Amazon. If those clicks are driven by pages, or a business, or a site where infringement is taking place, then it is fairly straightforward to make an argument that Amazon is indirectly profiting from AND supporting copyright infringement. How much indirection is enough for a company to wash its hands of liability? This is a tough question to answer. Extreme positions on this argument almost never make sense.

So we get sarcastic comments that maybe we should hold steel miners liable for gun deaths, because they mined the steel that made the machines that made the guns and the bullets that someone eventually used to commit murder. Slightly less sarcastic are the occasional ads we see on Microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free that link drug money to supporting terrorism.

And then I see ridiculous arguments on the other side that reason that a single layer of indirection should more or less absolve you of responsibility. The U.

Courts have taken a middle-way approach here. They have been fairly consistent at finding liability only where there were additional contributing factors: material participation, behavior that encourages infringement, and so on.

This was the key distinguishing factor in, e. The entire point of an affiliate business is to pay competitors to advertise your products? While you may disagree that Amazon and Cuda. Maybe, maybe not. Maybe without paying Cuda. Maybe it will reduce the number of people less educated about copyright law and the realities of affiliate programs who go to the Cuda.

Whether they realize it or not, Google and the newspapers are in the same business content aggregationand Google is better at it than the newspapers.

There is no mental calculation you could make where this is encouraging piracy. It makes no sense to me. Compare the site with Amazon and without. Then say which gets more infringement. Then explain how anyone could possibly assume this is Amazon inducing infringement.

NO analysis would find them to be promoting infringing. Do you think more people would a buy via the affiliate link on this site if the links were left or b go to some other file sharing site and never buy if this site went away. I give up. That is more idiotic than what you said earlier. At all. Yes, Amazon is certainly going to alienate a lot of smart investors by turning away a tiny amount of money to avoid the very real possibility of infinitely more expensive legal proceedings. If change were that simple, it would have been done microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free.

By this statement am I to microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free you think the law should be changed to strip all rights from those who create music so you can take it from them without the fear of suffering any sort of penalty for doing so? The copyright law is specifically written to make creators the initial owners of all rights to whatever they create. To prevent creators from assigning those rights to others they believe might be useful in developing their careers — like record companies, motion picture production companies et al, the people you live to hate — you would have to take creators rights away from them by eliminating copyright laws entirely.

With that sort of unthinking, uncaring, uneducated attitude, you know who you are really screwing? I am microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free sure it is. How about a microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free example? I suppose we should just eliminate prom nights then, although that seems to me a much more rash and idiotic course of actions than punishing on a per-case basis since eliminating prom night punishes so many more than just the infringers….

Thanks Bro. Perhaps Ms. Sotomayor will be nominated to replace Mr. Souter on the Supreme Court, in which case we would have a highly respected jurist who prior to ascending to the federal bench served in substantial part as a copyright attorney. BTW, Grokster was a 9 to 0 decision.

Perhaps you may wish to consider holding a placard outside of the Supreme Court informing them that they are mistaken. If you are lucky, maybe you would be joined by members of The Pirate Party who would also be holding placards. Now, though, I agree that Google is on the decline. Hold on there. Amazon allowing the association of their trusted, high quality, fully licensed, legal brand with an illegitimate, unauthorized, malware infested piece of garbage site gives the appearance of legitimizing creeps and tarnishes the Amazon brand making it more microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free for them to deal effectively with the sources of the legitimate product they sell.

A trademarked super brand like Amazon needs to do everything in its power to protect its image. I want a good looking one to be showed on my library.

Congratulations on your attempt to stifle free speech by calling me a troll. Everstealth is the worlds most popular mobile phone and computer monitoring tool. It can be used to eavesdrop on conversations, internet access, calendar appointments, text messages, pictures, videos, e-mails and other activity. Your email address will not be published. Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here. Subscribe to the Techdirt Daily newsletter.

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop ».

Read All ». Become an Insider! This feature is only available to registered users. You can register here or sign in to use it. Sign In Register Preferences. Mis Uses of Technology. Fri, May 1st pm - Mike Masnick. If you liked this post, you may also be interested in Rate this comment as insightful.

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment. Threaded [2] And…how exactly microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free these people engaging in copyright infringement via Amazon, hmm? Yes, it is illegal in most cases. We agree totally. Against Amazon being stupid?!? Threaded [3] Huh? Clear expression. Affirmative steps. Threaded [4] Amazon pays affiliates when clicked links turn into purchases, which create profits for Amazon.

Honestly, your argument makes no sense. Case closed. Are you serious? Threaded [3] The internet Threaded [3] By this statement am I to assume you think the law should be changed to strip all rights from those who create music so you can take it from them without the fear of suffering any sort of penalty for doing so?

Microsoft office 2007 enterprise edition blaze69 free creators is not the most effective way to encourage them to create. Threaded [4] Wow.